How do you ask questions that challenge and clarify arguments?
Asking questions is a powerful way to improve your critical thinking skills, especially when you encounter arguments that are complex, unclear, or controversial. By asking questions that challenge and clarify arguments, you can expose hidden assumptions, reveal logical flaws, and evaluate evidence more effectively. In this article, you will learn some tips and strategies for asking questions that challenge and clarify arguments.
The first step to ask questions that challenge and clarify arguments is to identify the main claim and reasons that support it. The main claim is the conclusion or the point that the argument is trying to make. The reasons are the premises or the evidence that back up the main claim. To identify the main claim and reasons, you can look for indicator words, such as therefore, because, since, or hence. You can also restate the argument in your own words and check if it makes sense. For example, if the argument is "You should eat more fruits and vegetables, because they are rich in vitamins and minerals", the main claim is "You should eat more fruits and vegetables" and the reason is "they are rich in vitamins and minerals".
To evaluate the relevance and sufficiency of the reasons, you can ask questions such as how does this reason support the main claim, is it based on facts, opinions, or assumptions, and is it consistent with other reasons and evidence? Additionally, you can ask if this reason is enough to accept the main claim and if there are any counterexamples or exceptions that weaken this reason. For example, if the reason is "they are rich in vitamins and minerals", you can ask: How does being rich in vitamins and minerals support the claim that you should eat more fruits and vegetables? Is this reason based on facts or opinions? Is this reason consistent with other nutritional advice? Is this reason enough to convince someone who does not like fruits and vegetables? Are there any other sources of vitamins and minerals that are equally or more beneficial? Asking these questions can help determine if the reasons given are relevant and sufficient to support the main claim.
Assessing the validity and soundness of an argument is the final step in asking questions that challenge and clarify arguments. The validity of an argument is determined by how well it follows the rules of logic and avoids fallacies, while the soundness of an argument is based on its reasons and evidence. To assess the validity and soundness of an argument, you can ask questions such as: does the argument have a clear and coherent structure? Does it avoid logical fallacies? Does it acknowledge and address any objections or alternatives? Are its sources of information credible and relevant? And does it use clear and precise language and definitions? As an example, if the argument is "You should eat more fruits and vegetables, because they are rich in vitamins and minerals", you can ask: does the argument have a clear structure or is it missing any steps or links? Does it avoid appealing to authority, popularity, or emotion? Are there any objections or alternatives such as dietary restrictions, preferences, or costs that should be addressed? Are its sources of information scientific studies, experts, or statistics? And does it use precise language and definitions for what counts as fruits and vegetables, how much is more, or what are the benefits of vitamins and minerals?
-
*Starting with questions that focus on conceptual analysis and understanding is a smart approach* For instance, you might ask things like: - "Could you explain the main concept you're talking about?" - "What do you mean by.. .? - "Can you give an example to illustrate this concept?" - "What are the key ideas behind your argument? These questions help ensure everyone is on the same page and understands the basics. It's like setting up a strong base for a more in-depth conversation. Once everyone gets the main ideas, you can move on to discussing details and examples to make the conversation even more interesting and helpful. This approach makes the conversation meaningful and helps everyone engage better.