[go: nahoru, domu]

Jump to content

Milavče train crash: Difference between revisions

Coordinates: 49°27′55″N 12°59′6″E / 49.46528°N 12.98500°E / 49.46528; 12.98500
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
m replaced "accident" with more appropriate "crash"
c/e
 
(11 intermediate revisions by 7 users not shown)
Line 18: Line 18:
| date = {{Start date|2021|08|04|df=y}}
| date = {{Start date|2021|08|04|df=y}}
| time = 08:06 [[Central European Summer Time|CEST]] (06:06 [[Coordinated Universal Time|UTC]])
| time = 08:06 [[Central European Summer Time|CEST]] (06:06 [[Coordinated Universal Time|UTC]])
| location = [[Milavče]]
| location = [[Milavče]], [[Domažlice District|Domažlice Dictrict]]
| location_dir =
| location_dir =
| location_city =
| location_city =
Line 26: Line 26:
| line =
| line =
| operator = *[[České dráhy]] (local train)
| operator = *[[České dráhy]] (local train)
*[[Die Länderbahn]]/České dráhy (international train)
*[[Die Länderbahn]]/České dráhy (express train)
| owner =
| owner =
| service = *[[Plzeň]]–[[Domažlice]] (local train)
| service = *[[Plzeň]]–[[Domažlice]] (local train)
*[[Munich]]–[[Prague]] (international train)
*[[Munich]]–[[Prague]] (express train)
| type = Head-on collision
| type = Head-on collision
| cause =
| cause =
Line 36: Line 36:
| trains = 2
| trains = 2
| vehicles =
| vehicles =
| passengers =
| passengers = *~60 (express train)
*~7 (local train)
| crew =
| crew =
| pedestrians =
| pedestrians =
| deaths = 3
| deaths = 3
| injuries = 67
| injuries = 67
| missing = 1
| missing =
| damage = In excess of [[Czech koruna|Kč]] 100,000,000
| damage = [[Czech koruna|Kč]] 178,000,000
| property =
| property =
<!-- Route map -->
<!-- Route map -->
Line 54: Line 55:


== Background ==
== Background ==
The collision occurred at 8:06 a.m. local time on the outskirts of the village of Milavče. The passenger train of the [[České dráhy]] Os 7406 was travelling on the route [[Plzeň main railway station|Plzeň hlavní nádraží]] - [[Domažlice railway station|Domažlice]] and consisted of a [[Pesa Link|RegioShark]] diesel unit (844.006-7). The international express Ex 351 Západní expres (''"Western Express"'') went from [[München Hauptbahnhof|München Hbf]] to [[Praha hlavní nádraží]] and consisted of a [[Eurorunner|Siemens ER20]] diesel locomotive (223.066-2) and four passenger cars.<ref>{{cite web |last1=Maňák |first1=Vratislav |last2=Musil |first2=Adam |title=Na Chodsku se srazil rychlík z Bavorska a RegioShark, tři lidé zemřeli |url=https://ct24.ceskatelevize.cz/regiony/3350074-na-domazlicku-se-srazily-vlaky-desitky-lidi-jsou-zraneny |website=ČT24 |access-date=7 October 2023}}</ref><ref>{{cite web |last1=Majdlová |first1=Klára |last2=Mencl |first2=Petr |title=Závěrečná zpráva o výsledcích šetření mimořádné události – Srážka vlaku Ex 351 s protijedoucím vlakem Os 7406 ve výhybně Radonice |url=https://www.dicr.cz/mimoradne-udalosti/setrene-mimoradne-udalosti-a-zaverecne-zpravy/vyhybna-radonice |website=Drážní inspekce}}</ref> On the German territory, the train was operated by the German carrier [[Die Länderbahn|Die Länderbahn GmbH]] under the brand name "[[Die Länderbahn#alex|alex]]", and on the Czech territory was operated by České dráhy. From [[Munich|München]] to [[Schwandorf]], the train was driven by a German driver and from Schwandorf to [[Prague|Praha]] was driven by a Czech driver.
Train collisions in the Czech Republic are relatively frequent by European standards because of outdated safety systems.<ref name=":0" /> After a deadly collision in 2020,{{cn|date=August 2021}} the [[Czech government]] announced a modernization programme. As of 2021 the [[European Train Control System]] (ETCS) is installed on only {{cvt|500|km}} of rail; by 2025 this is planned to be expanded to all main lines.<ref name=":0">{{Cite web|title=Zug aus München in Tschechien verunglückt: Drei Tote |trans-title=Train from Munich crashed in the Czech Republic: three dead |url=https://www.sueddeutsche.de/bayern/unfaelle-344-01-milavce-tschechien-zug-aus-muenchen-in-tschechien-verunglueckt-drei-tote-dpa.urn-newsml-dpa-com-20090101-210804-99-702817|url-status=live|access-date=2021-08-05|website=[[Süddeutsche Zeitung]]|language=de}}</ref>

Despite its importance and load, [[:cs:Železniční trať Plzeň – Furth im Wald/wiki/Železniční trať Plzeň – Furth im Wald|the line]] from [[Plzeň]] to [[Domažlice]] is single-track, so opposite coming trains must cross at stations or at [[passing loop]]s. The line is equipped with standard security, but not with the [[European Train Control System|ETCS]].


==Crash==
==Crash==
According to the timetable, the trains were to cross at the Radonice passing loop, near Milavče. The express arrived at the passing loop first, and therefore had to wait for the oncoming passenger train.
Two passenger trains collided head-on at Milavče, [[Plzeň Region]], Czech Republic at 08:06 [[Central European Summer Time|local time]] (06:06 [[Coordinated Universal Time|UTC]]).<ref name=Yahoo083718946/><ref name=CT24-3350074/> One of the trains was a [[České dráhy]] local service<ref name=Yahoo091354150>{{cite web |url=https://news.yahoo.com/passenger-trains-collide-czech-republic-091354150.html |title=Passenger trains collide in Czech Republic, killing 2 |publisher=Yahoo News |access-date=4 August 2021 |archive-date=4 August 2021 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20210804152032/https://news.yahoo.com/passenger-trains-collide-czech-republic-091354150.html |url-status=live }}</ref> from [[Plzeň main railway station|Plzeň]] to [[Domažlice]],<ref name="Reuters040821">{{cite web |url=https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/two-dead-after-trains-collide-czech-republic-news-agency-ctk-2021-08-04/ |title=Munich-Prague train collides with Czech commuter service, three dead |first=Jiri |last=Skacel |publisher=Reuters |access-date=4 August 2021 |archive-date=4 August 2021 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20210804151325/https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/two-dead-after-trains-collide-czech-republic-news-agency-ctk-2021-08-04/ |url-status=live }}</ref> with [[ČD Class 844]] RegioShark [[diesel multiple unit]] 844 006.<ref name=CT24-3350074/><ref name=SZ171475>{{cite web |url=https://www.seznamzpravy.cz/clanek/minuta-po-minute-jak-doslo-k-tragicke-srazce-vlaku-na-domazlicku-171475 |title=Minuta po minutě: Jak došlo k tragické srážce vlaků na Domažlicku |trans-title=Minute by minute: How did the tragic collision of trains in Domažlice |language=cs |publisher=Seznam Zprávy |first=Dávid |last=Pásztor |date=4 August 2021 |accessdate=6 August 2021}}</ref> The other was an international service from [[Munich]], Germany to [[Prague]], Czech Republic,<ref name="Nine050821">{{cite web|date=5 August 2021|title=Three dead, dozens injured after passenger trains collide in the Czech Republic|url=https://www.9news.com.au/world/czech-republic-train-crash-three-dead-dozens-injured-after-passenger-trains-collide-in-czech-town-of-milavce|publisher=Channel 9 News|access-date=4 August 2021}}</ref><ref name="CNN040821">{{cite web |url=https://edition.cnn.com/2021/08/04/europe/train-crash-domazlice-czech-republic-intl/index.html |title=Two dead, more than 40 injured in Czech train crash |publisher=CNN |access-date=4 August 2021 |archive-date=4 August 2021 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20210804151747/https://edition.cnn.com/2021/08/04/europe/train-crash-domazlice-czech-republic-intl/index.html |url-status=live }}</ref> operated by České dráhy in the Czech Republic and by [[Die Länderbahn]] in Germany.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.merkur.de/welt/zugunglueck-tschechien-muenchen-prag-alex-aktuell-domazlice-bayern-pilsen-zr-90900742.html|title=Expresszug aus München kollidiert mit Regionalbahn nahe Bayerns Grenze – Weiterer Toter gemeldet |trans-title=Express train from Munich collides with regional train near Bavaria's border - another dead reported |language=de |publisher=[[Münchner Merkur]]|date=4 August 2021|access-date=5 August 2021}}</ref> The train was hauled by [[Eurorunner|Class 223]] [[diesel locomotive]] 223 066.<ref name=CT24-3350074/>

At the entrance to the passing loop, the yellow light (the "Warning" signal) was on at the entrance signal, informing the driver that the red light (the "Stop" signal) was on at the departure signal and he needed to start slowing down. However, the express driver did not start to slow down and kept to the maximum speed, which in this section is 80 kph.

Meanwhile, the passenger train left the Milavče stop, about 900 metres away from the passing loop, and drove towards to the passing loop.
Without stopping, the express passed the departure signal in the "Stop" position, left the passing loop back onto the single-track line, and collided head-on with the passenger train a few seconds later.
Both drivers applied the speed brake, but the collision could not be avoided. The express was travelling at approximately 77 kph at the time of impact, the passenger train at 40 kph. The faster and heavier express train pushed the passenger train back as a result of the impact by approximately 75 metres.<ref>{{cite web |last1=Majdlová |first1=Klára |last2=Mencl |first2=Petr |title=Závěrečná zpráva o výsledcích šetření mimořádné události – Srážka vlaku Ex 351 s protijedoucím vlakem Os 7406 ve výhybně Radonice |url=https://www.dicr.cz/mimoradne-udalosti/setrene-mimoradne-udalosti-a-zaverecne-zpravy/vyhybna-radonice |website=Drážní inspekce}}</ref>

==Aftermath==
The impact severely damaged both trains. The front part of the RegioShark unit was badly damaged, the driver's cab was completely demolished and the front bogie broke off and lay loose on the tracks between the trains.
[[File:RegioShark Milavce1.jpg|thumb|The destroyed front part of the RegioShark unit involved in the crash, parked at the [[Blížejov]] train station in October 2021. The less damaged rear part was taken to the depot in Plzeň as a source of spare parts, the more damaged part (pictured) was later scrapped.]][[File:RegioShark Milavce2.jpg|thumb|The remains of the driver's cab]]

The Siemens locomotive pulling the express derailed with three axles on impact and its front end, including the driver's cab, was completely destroyed. The first car behind the locomotive was pushed onto the locomotive by the other cars, partially derailed and broke. The remaining three cars were less severely damaged.<ref>{{cite web |last1=Majdlová |first1=Klára |last2=Mencl |first2=Petr |title=Závěrečná zpráva o výsledcích šetření mimořádné události – Srážka vlaku Ex 351 s protijedoucím vlakem Os 7406 ve výhybně Radonice |url=https://www.dicr.cz/mimoradne-udalosti/setrene-mimoradne-udalosti-a-zaverecne-zpravy/vyhybna-radonice |website=Drážní inspekce}}</ref>

The first report of the crash was received by emergency operators at 8:08 a.m. All components of the Integrated Rescue System immediately rushed to the site. Dozens of rescuers and firefighters, including three helicopters of the Air Rescue Service and a helicopter of the [[Police of the Czech Republic]], intervened at the scene. In addition to Czech rescuers, several teams of rescuers and firefighters from Germany intervened to take care of the German-speaking passengers. The injured were taken to hospitals in [[Plzeň]], [[Domažlice]], [[Klatovy]], [[Stod (Plzeň-South District)|Stod]] and [[Prague|Praha]], while 10 German-speaking passengers were taken to hospitals in [[Germany]]. Rescuers treated a total of 67 injured people.<ref>{{cite web |last1=Maňák |first1=Vratislav |last2=Musil |first2=Adam |title=Na Chodsku se srazil rychlík z Bavorska a RegioShark, tři lidé zemřeli |url=https://ct24.ceskatelevize.cz/regiony/3350074-na-domazlicku-se-srazily-vlaky-desitky-lidi-jsou-zraneny |website=ČT24 |access-date=7 October 2023}}</ref>


Three people, a passenger from the passenger train and both drivers, did not survive the collision. The driver of the express was presumed missing for a few hours before his body was recovered from the locomotive by firefighters seven hours after the crash.
Three people were killed,<ref name="BBC58083778" /> and 67 were injured, five seriously.<ref name="Yahoo083718946">{{cite web |url=https://news.yahoo.com/two-dead-double-train-crash-083718946.htm |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20210804152115/https://news.yahoo.com/two-dead-double-train-crash-083718946.html |archive-date=4 August 2021 |title=Three dead after double train crash in Czech Republic |first=Jon |last=Sharman |publisher=Yahoo News |access-date=4 August 2021}}</ref><ref name="CT24-3350074">{{cite web |url=https://ct24.ceskatelevize.cz/regiony/3350074-na-domazlicku-se-srazily-vlaky-desitky-lidi-jsou-zraneny |title=Na Chodsku se srazil rychlík z Bavorska a RegioShark, tři lidé zemřeli |trans-title=An express train from Bavaria and RegioShark collided in Chodsko, three people died |language=cs |publisher=[[Czech Television]]|access-date=4 August 2021 }}</ref> Those killed were both drivers and a female passenger, all Czech citizens.<ref name="BBC58083778" /> One person was reported missing.<ref name="CNN040821"/>


Minister of Transport [[Karel Havlíček (politician)|Karel Havlíček]] also arrived at the scene, confirming the three victims and saying that the cause of the accident was probably the express running through the "Stop" signal.<ref>{{cite web |last1=Hříbal |first1=Antonín |last2=Mrázová |first2=Klára |title=U Milavče na Domažlicku se srazily dva vlaky, o život přišli oba strojvedoucí |url=https://domazlicky.denik.cz/nehody/u-milavce-na-domazlicku-se-srazily-dva-vlaky-20210804.html |website=Domažlický deník |access-date=7 October 2023}}</ref>
Rescuers from Germany assisted their Czech colleagues. Four [[helicopter]]s transported the injured to hospitals in Plzeň.<ref name="CNN040821" /> Ten less severely injured patients were transported to hospitals in Germany.<ref name="Reuters040821" /> Damages were estimated as in excess of [[Czech koruna|Kč]] 100,000,000 (about 3.9 million Euro or 4.6 million [[US$]]).<ref name="CT24-3350074" />
The line remained closed after the accident, with the first train passing the site at 18:30 on 6 August 2021.<ref>{{cite web |last1=ČTK |title=Trať u Milavče je po tragické srážce vlaků znovu průjezdná. Opraveno bylo 109 pražců |url=https://www.irozhlas.cz/zpravy-domov/trat-nehode-vlaky-milavce-znovu-prujezdna_2108061857_piv |website=iRozhlas |access-date=7 October 2023}}</ref>


==Investigations==
==Investigations==
Drážní inspekce (Railway Inspectorate) launched an investigation on the day of the crash. In March 2022, it released its final report in which stated that the accident was caused by the driver of the express train who failed to stop at the signal in the "Stop" position. It ruled out poor signal visibility or a technical fault on the locomotive.<ref>{{cite web |last1=Majdlová |first1=Klára |last2=Mencl |first2=Petr |title=Závěrečná zpráva o výsledcích šetření mimořádné události – Srážka vlaku Ex 351 s protijedoucím vlakem Os 7406 ve výhybně Radonice |url=https://www.dicr.cz/mimoradne-udalosti/setrene-mimoradne-udalosti-a-zaverecne-zpravy/vyhybna-radonice |website=Drážní inspekce}}</ref>
The [[Rail Safety Inspection Office]] (RSIO {{lang-cs|Drážní inspekce}}) opened an investigation into the crash.<ref name=BBC58083778>{{cite web |url=https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-58083778 |title=Three dead in train crash near Czech-German border |publisher=BBC News Online |access-date=4 August 2021 |archive-date=4 August 2021 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20210804151512/https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-58083778 |url-status=live }}</ref> The investigation is expected to take several months. A criminal investigation was also opened as negligence was suspected to be one of the causes of the crash. České dráhy likewise opened an investigation into the crash.<ref name="CT24-3350074" />


The investigation was also launched by the Czech Police on suspicion of committing the crime of general danger due to negligence. The investigation was eventually postponed because the express driver, who was at fault, died in the collision.<ref>{{cite web |last1=Bílá |first1=Valentýna |last2=ČTK |title=U Milavčí vyprostili zdemolovanou lokomotivu, na jeřáb museli dát závaží |url=https://www.idnes.cz/plzen/zpravy/vlak-srazka-nehoda-milavce-vyprosteni-domazlice-zeleznice.A210805_083200_plzen-zpravy_vb |website=iDNES}}</ref>
Czech transport minister [[Karel Havlíček (politician)|Karel Havlíček]] said that the international train had [[Signal passed at danger|passed a stop signal]] (SPAD).<ref name="CNN040821" /> Inspector General of the RSIO Jan Kučera said that it was not known whether the SPAD was a result of a technical defect with the train or driver error.<ref name="CT24-3350074" />


==References==
==References==

Latest revision as of 21:09, 28 February 2024

Milavče train crash
A ČD Class 844 RegioShark diesel multiple unit, similar to that involved in the crash
The Class 223 diesel locomotive 223-066 involved in the crash
Milavče train crash is located in Czech Republic
Milavče train crash
Milavče, Czech Republic
Details
Date4 August 2021 (2021-08-04)
08:06 CEST (06:06 UTC)
LocationMilavče, Domažlice Dictrict
Coordinates49°27′55″N 12°59′6″E / 49.46528°N 12.98500°E / 49.46528; 12.98500
CountryCzech Republic
Operator
Service
Incident typeHead-on collision
Statistics
Trains2
Passengers
  • ~60 (express train)
  • ~7 (local train)
Deaths3
Injured67
Damage 178,000,000

On 4 August 2021, two passenger trains collided at Milavče in the Czech Republic. Three people were killed and 67 were injured.

Background

[edit]

The collision occurred at 8:06 a.m. local time on the outskirts of the village of Milavče. The passenger train of the České dráhy Os 7406 was travelling on the route Plzeň hlavní nádraží - Domažlice and consisted of a RegioShark diesel unit (844.006-7). The international express Ex 351 Západní expres ("Western Express") went from München Hbf to Praha hlavní nádraží and consisted of a Siemens ER20 diesel locomotive (223.066-2) and four passenger cars.[1][2] On the German territory, the train was operated by the German carrier Die Länderbahn GmbH under the brand name "alex", and on the Czech territory was operated by České dráhy. From München to Schwandorf, the train was driven by a German driver and from Schwandorf to Praha was driven by a Czech driver.

Despite its importance and load, the line from Plzeň to Domažlice is single-track, so opposite coming trains must cross at stations or at passing loops. The line is equipped with standard security, but not with the ETCS.

Crash

[edit]

According to the timetable, the trains were to cross at the Radonice passing loop, near Milavče. The express arrived at the passing loop first, and therefore had to wait for the oncoming passenger train.

At the entrance to the passing loop, the yellow light (the "Warning" signal) was on at the entrance signal, informing the driver that the red light (the "Stop" signal) was on at the departure signal and he needed to start slowing down. However, the express driver did not start to slow down and kept to the maximum speed, which in this section is 80 kph.

Meanwhile, the passenger train left the Milavče stop, about 900 metres away from the passing loop, and drove towards to the passing loop. Without stopping, the express passed the departure signal in the "Stop" position, left the passing loop back onto the single-track line, and collided head-on with the passenger train a few seconds later. Both drivers applied the speed brake, but the collision could not be avoided. The express was travelling at approximately 77 kph at the time of impact, the passenger train at 40 kph. The faster and heavier express train pushed the passenger train back as a result of the impact by approximately 75 metres.[3]

Aftermath

[edit]

The impact severely damaged both trains. The front part of the RegioShark unit was badly damaged, the driver's cab was completely demolished and the front bogie broke off and lay loose on the tracks between the trains.

The destroyed front part of the RegioShark unit involved in the crash, parked at the Blížejov train station in October 2021. The less damaged rear part was taken to the depot in Plzeň as a source of spare parts, the more damaged part (pictured) was later scrapped.
The remains of the driver's cab

The Siemens locomotive pulling the express derailed with three axles on impact and its front end, including the driver's cab, was completely destroyed. The first car behind the locomotive was pushed onto the locomotive by the other cars, partially derailed and broke. The remaining three cars were less severely damaged.[4]

The first report of the crash was received by emergency operators at 8:08 a.m. All components of the Integrated Rescue System immediately rushed to the site. Dozens of rescuers and firefighters, including three helicopters of the Air Rescue Service and a helicopter of the Police of the Czech Republic, intervened at the scene. In addition to Czech rescuers, several teams of rescuers and firefighters from Germany intervened to take care of the German-speaking passengers. The injured were taken to hospitals in Plzeň, Domažlice, Klatovy, Stod and Praha, while 10 German-speaking passengers were taken to hospitals in Germany. Rescuers treated a total of 67 injured people.[5]

Three people, a passenger from the passenger train and both drivers, did not survive the collision. The driver of the express was presumed missing for a few hours before his body was recovered from the locomotive by firefighters seven hours after the crash.

Minister of Transport Karel Havlíček also arrived at the scene, confirming the three victims and saying that the cause of the accident was probably the express running through the "Stop" signal.[6] The line remained closed after the accident, with the first train passing the site at 18:30 on 6 August 2021.[7]

Investigations

[edit]

Drážní inspekce (Railway Inspectorate) launched an investigation on the day of the crash. In March 2022, it released its final report in which stated that the accident was caused by the driver of the express train who failed to stop at the signal in the "Stop" position. It ruled out poor signal visibility or a technical fault on the locomotive.[8]

The investigation was also launched by the Czech Police on suspicion of committing the crime of general danger due to negligence. The investigation was eventually postponed because the express driver, who was at fault, died in the collision.[9]

References

[edit]
  1. ^ Maňák, Vratislav; Musil, Adam. "Na Chodsku se srazil rychlík z Bavorska a RegioShark, tři lidé zemřeli". ČT24. Retrieved 7 October 2023.
  2. ^ Majdlová, Klára; Mencl, Petr. "Závěrečná zpráva o výsledcích šetření mimořádné události – Srážka vlaku Ex 351 s protijedoucím vlakem Os 7406 ve výhybně Radonice". Drážní inspekce.
  3. ^ Majdlová, Klára; Mencl, Petr. "Závěrečná zpráva o výsledcích šetření mimořádné události – Srážka vlaku Ex 351 s protijedoucím vlakem Os 7406 ve výhybně Radonice". Drážní inspekce.
  4. ^ Majdlová, Klára; Mencl, Petr. "Závěrečná zpráva o výsledcích šetření mimořádné události – Srážka vlaku Ex 351 s protijedoucím vlakem Os 7406 ve výhybně Radonice". Drážní inspekce.
  5. ^ Maňák, Vratislav; Musil, Adam. "Na Chodsku se srazil rychlík z Bavorska a RegioShark, tři lidé zemřeli". ČT24. Retrieved 7 October 2023.
  6. ^ Hříbal, Antonín; Mrázová, Klára. "U Milavče na Domažlicku se srazily dva vlaky, o život přišli oba strojvedoucí". Domažlický deník. Retrieved 7 October 2023.
  7. ^ ČTK. "Trať u Milavče je po tragické srážce vlaků znovu průjezdná. Opraveno bylo 109 pražců". iRozhlas. Retrieved 7 October 2023.
  8. ^ Majdlová, Klára; Mencl, Petr. "Závěrečná zpráva o výsledcích šetření mimořádné události – Srážka vlaku Ex 351 s protijedoucím vlakem Os 7406 ve výhybně Radonice". Drážní inspekce.
  9. ^ Bílá, Valentýna; ČTK. "U Milavčí vyprostili zdemolovanou lokomotivu, na jeřáb museli dát závaží". iDNES.