Wikipedia:Files for discussion/2024 July 14: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
TheWikiToby (talk | contribs) |
|||
Line 457:
:[[File:Symbol keep vote.svg|15px|link=]]'''Speedily keep''' Fair use, and the related incident needs proper visual identification. Maybe use the entire portion and move it to the infobox, but otherwise, no, this file ''needs'' to be on the Wikipedia until an adequate free alternative exists. [[User:AuroraANovaUma|AuroraANovaUma ^-^]] ([[User talk:AuroraANovaUma|talk]]) 21:48, 14 July 2024 (UTC)
::Furthermore, this is not the first time an image tagged under the historic image template was used in such a way. We may need more than one template to describe that though. Regardless, I still feel that visual identification of the incident is desperately needed. [[User:AuroraANovaUma|AuroraANovaUma ^-^]] ([[User talk:AuroraANovaUma|talk]]) 21:58, 14 July 2024 (UTC)
* '''Delete''' - it's fails [[WP:NFCC]] #2, arguably fails NFCC #1. For example, in addition to Vucci's photos, Getty Images includes photos from Rebecca Droke and Jeff Swensen, and I'm sure many others exist as well. Including this picture in Wikipedia at this point in time makes it less likely for someone to upload their own version to Commons. [[User:Guettarda|Guettarda]] ([[User talk:Guettarda|talk]]) 23:47, 14 July 2024 (UTC)
* '''Delete''' Unfortunately, per copyright law and fair use law, this photo does not appear to qualify. Any fair use claim is especially knocked down not only because the article of use isn't about the photo, but also because there are large number of other photos also being used in the media about the incident, thus fair use doesn't cover this particular image as a singular representative use. I hope the closer of this discussion takes into account copyright law and WP policy requirements, rather than all the Keep votes above that aren't putting forward a policy argument or even addressing the copyright fair use concerns. [[User:Silver seren|<span style="color: dimgrey;">Silver</span>]][[User talk:Silver seren|<span style="color: blue;">seren</span>]]<sup>[[Special:Contributions/Silver seren|C]]</sup> 23:41, 14 July 2024 (UTC)
| |||
