The Voldemort effect is a social phenomenon where people are fearful of naming someone, to speak of something or acknowledge it exists, and therefore derail any attempt to confront it.[1][2] The phrase takes cue from the line associated with Lord Voldemort in the Harry Potter series: 'he who must not be named', because they are terrified to name him or they deny his existence.[3][4][5][6]
Background
The expression was popularized by British activist Maajid Nawaz in 2015, where he applied it for analysts, experts, social commentators and politicians, among others, who are fearful or hesitant to call out the ideology of Islamism as the underlying cause of Jihadist terrorism.[7] Nawaz stated that people refusing to acknowledge radical Islam are comparable to members of Hogwarts who refuse to mention Voldemort's name, and by declining to name him, they forestall an open discussion from taking place about an accomplishable solution, which therefore exacerbates the situation, causes more dread and panic, and further glorifies the myth of his powerful nature.[8] As Majid puts it, "Refusing to name a problem, and failing to recognize it, is never a good way to solve it".[6]
History of usage
The earliest usage of "Voldemort effect" was in an Australian infant health research in 2008 which reported that formula feeding was seldom named in publication titles or abstracts as a health risk factor for babies.[9]
The term was used in 2011 for American politics, which had a different meaning, and was used to describe politicians who point out their favorite political figures just to ardently cite the ability to "drive the other side crazy."[4]
In a 2013 Christian book Holding Your Family Together by Dr. Rich Melheim, the term was used for those who do not want speak the name of something that is frightening them or causing problems to them. The author encouraged the reader to "to name that sucker out loud...We are going to call him what he is and who he is so that we can deal with real problem, not the myth", because after mentioning the unspeakable name, "The moment the silence is broken, the power starts to drain away from its sinister source and move in the direction of those who dare deal with it.[10]
The term was used for COVID-19 during the pandemic in 2020, as people began to ignore the social distancing rules and even dismissing the existence of the virus. The term was applied in this context because COVID-19 is a serious issue that threatened peace in the world, in addition to people treating like it did not exist, just the same way Voldemort was a menace to peace and continued to be a serious problem for years, despite the fact that many in the Wizarding World chose to deny his return.[11]
Islam
"I call this the Voldemort effect, after the villain in J.K. Rowling's Harry Potter books. Many well-meaning people in Ms. Rowling's fictional world are so petrified of Voldemort's evil that they do two things: They refuse to call Voldemort by name, instead referring to 'He Who Must Not Be Named,' and they deny that he exists in the first place. Such dread only increases public hysteria, thus magnifying the appeal of Voldemort's power."
Maajid Nawaz, My Origin, My Destiny Christianity's Basic "Value Proposition"[8]
After Nawaz's vulgarization of the phrase in 2015, it has since been used to criticize mainly left-wingers who vociferously condemn any legitimate criticism of Islam and instead bring up whataboutisms such as the Crusades, with some even going far as blaming those who have fell victim to Islamic extremism after mocking the religion (such as the Charlie Hebdo cartoonists). This position has influenced the term 'Voldemort effect'; in the Harry Potter series it is a taboo to mention the Dark Wizard's name, and the taboo in this situation is to merely state that Islamic fascism is a "politicized religion" that should be open for criticism.[12]
In 2015, the term was used by British counter-terrorism expert Haras Rafiq, who remarked that Islamic extremism is treated like a "Lord Voldermort" taboo topic in the United Kingdom, whereby, according to him, the failure to label and condemn Islamist ideology (by western leaders) for what it i,s has encouraged young people to join ISIS. Rafiq stated, "it has so far very much been a Voldemort effect – he who shall not be named – with no-one actually coming out and saying it is an Islamist ideology."[13]
The Obama administration in particular has been criticized for not acknowledging radical Islam, and instead opting for the "violent extremism" rhetoric. An example of the obfuscation was after the Orlando nightclub shooting in 2016, the administration released highly redacted transcripts of the shooter's conversation with 911 dispatchers; his sworn allegiance to ISIS and his self-description as an "Islamic soldier" were omitted from the transcripts.[6]
See also
References
- ^ Brian Morris. "Islamism, Atheism And The 'Voldemort' Effect". Retrieved 30 January 2024.
- ^ Clara Henry (15 August 2017). I've Got My Period. So What?. Sky Pony Press. ISBN 9781510714236.
- ^ "Reformed ex-Islamist says society needs to take on 'Voldemort-effect'". Nine News Australia. Retrieved 30 January 2024.
- ^ a b Matthew Yglesias. "The Voldemort Effect". Retrieved 30 January 2024.
- ^ Rev. Peter Hendriks Okello (8 August 2018). The Real Deal: Making the Case for the One True God. FriesenPress. ISBN 9781525530234.
- ^ a b c Ali A. Rizvi (22 November 2016). The Atheist Muslim: A Journey from Religion to Reason. St. Martin's Publishing Group. ISBN 9781250094452.
- ^ Maajid Nawaz. "We Treat Radical Islam Like Voldemort — That's Bad for a Very Counterintuitive Reason". Retrieved 30 January 2024.
- ^ a b D.C. Collier (December 2016). My Origin, My Destiny Christianity's Basic "Value Proposition". WestBow Press. ISBN 9781512766202.
- ^ Julie P. Smith, Mark D Dunstone, Megan E Elliott-Rudder (December 2008). ‘Voldemort’ and health professional knowledge of breastfeeding – do journal titles and abstracts accurately convey findings on differential health outcomes for formula fed infants? (Report). Retrieved 30 January 2024.
{{cite report}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link) - ^ Dr. Rich Melheim (30 April 2013). Holding Your Family Together. Baker Publishing Group. ISBN 9781441266668.
- ^ Emiley Bailey. "The Voldemort Effect: College with COVID-19". Retrieved 30 January 2024.
- ^ Brian Morris (1 December 2015). "Islamism, atheism, and the 'Voldemort' effect". Retrieved 30 January 2024.
- ^ Matt Dathan. "Western leaders have been treating Islamic extremism like 'Lord Voldemort'". The Independent. Retrieved 30 January 2024.