Commons:Deletion requests/Files from cucutanuestra.com

This deletion discussion is now closed. Please do not make any edits to this archive. You can read the deletion policy or ask a question at the Village pump. If the circumstances surrounding this file have changed in a notable manner, you may re-nominate this file or ask for it to be undeleted.

Files from cucutanuestra.com

Unclear copyright status + all files from http://www.cucutanuestra.com (today: 404) are only in public domain by other reasons (via e.g. {{PD-Colombia}} but NOT via the ominous email-traffic, stored as "permission" at es:Wikipedia:Autorización Cucutanuestra.com (created by IP = ?) where states: "Cualquier material de mi página web cucutanuestra.com es de caracter público y puede publicarlo cuando quiera. Cordialmente: Guillermo Jaimes Ramírez." = (+/) Any material at my website is of public nature and can be publish if you want. The permission may be also available at Commons via ticket:1608869.

This is obviously not a permission which would fullfill COM:L and additionally it is highly doubtful if "Guillermo Jaimes Ramírez" is the copyright owner of all historic and actual images related to es:Cúcuta, a city in Colombia. So, all files from http://www.cucutanuestra.com need a case-by-case check, considering also:

All kinds of works available:

• satellite image
• copyrighted Panoramio images
• architectural sktetches
• historical images uncredited or credited to several organizations
• just on the main page around 100 audio files of music and some videos with unknown copyright status
• just on the main page full text of several books by different authors with unknown copyright status
• "Cortesía Profesor Caicedo y Almacén Andrés" / Courtesy by Professor "Caicedo y Almacén Andrés"
• "Cortesía de Claudio Barreto" / Courtesy by "Claudio Barreto" = this gallery
• "Cúcuta 2011" --> all photos works by "Luis Manuel Contreras"
• etc.

But also (and NOT nominating)

• File:Calle15cucuta.jpg

per archive a photo by "Guillermo Jaimes", the site owner.

Ignoring also some (historical) photos which probadly are already in PD. Weblink search.

Nominating:

• File:La Madre Teresa de Cúcuta.jpg --> sourced with (archive) http://web.archive.org/web/20090106135147/http://www.cucutanuestra.com/temas/fotos_cucuta/1980_1999/pages/406-%20La%20Madre%20Teresa%20de%20Calcuta..htm, credited with "Cortesía de La Cámara de Comercio" / Courtesy of Chamber of Commerce. Permission needed.
• File:Cúcuta, Colombia - Mapa Urbano.PNG --> a compex city map (archive), unlikely own work.
• File:Cucuta-detailed.png --> derivated
• File:Cúcuta - Casa - Mirador Campestre.jpg --> uncredited photo (archive)
• File:Policia Cúcuta Colombia.jpg --> per archive a work by "DIEGO ÁLVAREZ". Permission needed.
• File:Comcel Cúcuta.jpg --> uncredited photo (archive)
• File:Parque Grancolombiano - 1980.jpg --> no archive, uncredited.
• File:Cúcuta, Colombia - Mapa de Veredas.PNG --> map (archive). May be in PD by other reasons but relevant info must be provided.
• File:Norte de Santander, Colombia - Mapa de Hidrografía.PNG --> map (archive). May be in PD by other reasons but relevant info must be provided.
• File:Mapa Villa del Rosario Colombia.jpg --> complex map. May be in PD by other reasons but relevant info must be provided. No archive, per Google cache available at this index of maps.

Spezial case

• File:Escudo de Cucuta.svg --> coat of arms (archive). Unlikely own work. Per archived text established per decree on 03.02.1958. So far I know the actual Colombian copyright law makes no exception for government works. That would explain the license mess surfing through Category:Coats of arms of municipalities of Colombia = mostly all grabbed from Internet. Or is {{PD-Colombia}} (dot 4) relevant = "In all cases where a literary, scientific or artistic work has as its owner a legal entity or an official body or any institution under government public law, the term of protection shall be deemed to be seventy (70) years as from the date of publication." If yes, the coat of arms would be copyrighted till the end of 2028 (and all further edtions accordingly to their publication date).

--Gunnex (talk) 19:09, 1 September 2015 (UTC)

 Comment The coats of arms of Cucuta is an interpretation of the heraldry listed on the official website of the city (here), and since the heraldic science is allowed to make interpretations of the shields, I do not think it's copyrighted. All coats of arms of Colombia in commons in SVG format are interpretations of the heraldry and the law.--Shadowxfox (talk) 09:58, 2 September 2015 (UTC)

---

Deleted: per nom. JuTa 10:00, 15 October 2015 (UTC)