God of Vengeance (Yiddish: Got fun nekome) is a 1906 play by Sholem Asch. It is about a Jewish brothel owner who attempts to become respectable by commissioning a Torah Scroll and marrying off his daughter to a yeshiva student.
| God of Vengeance | |
|---|---|
| Written by | Sholem Asch |
| Date premiered | March 19, 1907 |
| Place premiered | Deutsches Theater |
| Original language | Yiddish |
| Subject | A Jewish brothel owner who attempts to become respectable by commissioning a Torah scroll and marrying off his daughter to a yeshiva student. |
| Genre | Drama |
Set in a brothel, the play explores themes of religious hypocrisy and morality. The play is notable for its progressive portrayal of a lesbian relationship, which was the first lesbian kiss on an American stage.[1] I. L. Peretz famously said of the play after reading it: "Burn it, Asch, burn it!" Instead, Asch went to Berlin and pitched it to director Max Reinhardt and actor Rudolph Schildkraut, who produced it at the Deutsches Theater.[2]
Production
editAsch wrote God of Vengeance in the winter of 1906 in Cologne, Germany.[3] The play was first brought to New York City, United States by David Kessler in 1907.[4]
God of Vengeance was published in English-language translation in 1918.[5] In 1922, it was staged in New York City at the Provincetown Theatre in Greenwich Village, and moved to the Apollo Theatre on Broadway on February 19, 1923, with a cast that included the acclaimed Jewish immigrant actor Rudolph Schildkraut.[6] Its run was cut short on March 8, when the entire cast, producer Harry Weinberger, and one of the owners of the theater were indicted for violating the New York Penal Code, and later convicted on charges of obscenity.[7] Weinberger, who was also a prominent attorney, represented the group at the trial.[8][9] The chief witness against the play was Rabbi Joseph Silverman, who declared in an interview with Forverts: "This play libels the Jewish religion. Even the greatest anti-Semite could not have written such a thing". After a lengthy legal battle, the conviction was successfully appealed.[10]
God of Vengeance was the first Yiddish play to be translated and staged throughout Europe. From Berlin, Asch went straight to St. Petersburg for the Russian-language premiere. Over the next few years Asch’s “brothel play” was also translated into Polish, Hebrew, English, Italian, French, Dutch, Czech, Swedish, and Norwegian. In 1912, the Moscow branch of the cinema firm Pathé Frères released a silent film of Got fun nekome with Russian titles.[11] According to film historian Jay Hoberman, it featured two Yiddish actors, Israel Arko and Misha Fishzon, at the head of a mainly non-Jewish cast.[citation needed] The film is now presumed lost.[citation needed] God of Vengeance found its greatest success on the Yiddish stage. Actor Dovid Kessler headed the cast of the New York Yiddish premiere and the play was also popular among the amateur Yiddish dramatic groups that flourished worldwide in the early twentieth century.[10]
In 2015, Paula Vogel created the play Indecent which she submitted as her Ph.D. dissertation at Cornell.[12] The play recounts the controversy surrounding the play. The play first premiered at the Yale Repertory Theatre in 2015,[13] followed by an off-Broadway run in 2016[14] and Broadway debut in 2017[15] for which it was nominated for three and won two Tony Awards.[16]
Synopsis
editThe play centers around Yankl Tchaptchovitch (Yekel Shepshovitch), a Jewish brothel owner who strives to maintain a façade of piety and respectability. He commissions a Torah scroll and aspires to marry off his daughter, Rivkele, to a scholar in hopes of distancing her from his sordid business. Despite his efforts to preserve her innocence, Rivkele falls in love with Manke, one of the prostitutes working in Yankl's brothel. Their relationship exposes the hypocrisy and moral corruption underlying Yankl's life.
Yankl's wife, Sarah, supports his ambitions but becomes increasingly conflicted as she witnesses the unfolding drama between Rivkele and Manke. The relationship between Rivkele and Manke becomes a catalyst for the unraveling of Yankl's carefully constructed world. When Rivkele's involvement with Manke is discovered, Yankl's plans for her future are shattered, and he descends into a desperate attempt to salvage his and his family's honor.
Cast
edit| Character | Original Broadway cast | 2016 Off-Off-Broadway Revival |
|---|---|---|
| Shloyme | Irwin J. Adler | Luzer Twersky |
| Hindel | Mae Berland | Caraid O’Brien |
| Reb Aaron | Morris Carnovsky | Eli Rosen |
| Reb Ali (Eli) | Sam Jaffe | David Mandelbaum |
| Rifkele (Rivke) | Virginia MacFadyen | Shayna Schmidt |
| Reb Yankev | James Meighan | Eli Rosen |
| Manke | Dorothee Nolan | Weisz |
| Yankl Tchaptchovitch (Yekel Shepshovitch) | Rudolph Schildkraut | Shane Baker |
| A Poor Woman | Marjorie Stewart | Amy Coleman |
| Sarah | Esther Stockton | Eleanor Reissa |
| Reizel (Reyzl) | Lillian Taiz | Rachel Botchan |
| Basha | Aldea Wise | Mira Kessler |
Original Broadway Cast at the Apollo Theatre.[17]
2016 New Yiddish Rep off-off-Broadway revival at La Mama.[18][19]
Background
editBorn into a Hasidic family, Sholem Asch received a traditional Jewish education. Considered the designated scholar of his siblings, his parents dreamed of him becoming a Rabbi and sent him to the town's best cheder. There, Asch spent most of his childhood studying the Talmud, and would later study the Bible and the Haggadah on his own time. Asch grew up in a majority Jewish town, so he grew up believing Jews were the majority in the rest of the world as well. In Kutno, Jews and gentiles mostly got along, barring some tension around religious holidays.[20]
In his adolescence, after moving from the cheder to the beth midrash, Sholem became aware of major social changes in popular Jewish thinking. New ideas and the Enlightenment were asserting themselves in the Jewish world. At his friend's house, Sholem would explore these new ideas by secretly reading many secular books, which led him to believe himself too worldly to become a Rabbi. At age 17, his parents found out about this "profane" literature and sent him to live with relatives in a nearby village, where he became a Hebrew teacher. After a few months there, he received a more liberal education at Włocławek, where he supported himself as a letter writer for the illiterate townspeople. It is in Włocławek where he became enamored with the work of prominent Yiddish writer I. L. Peretz. It is also where he began writing. He attempted to master the short story and wrote in Hebrew. What he wrote there would later be revised, translated into Yiddish, and ultimately, launch his career.[20]
In 1923, Scholem Asch wrote an open letter defending the play following the cast's arrest for obscenity which elaborated on the origins and early success of God of Vengeance. His letter said in part, "I wrote this play when I was twenty-one years of age. I was not concerned whether I wrote a moral or immoral play. What I wanted to write was an artistic play and a true one. In the seventeen years it has been before the public, this is the first time I have had to defend it. When the play was first produced, the critics in Germany, Russia, and other countries, said that it was too artistically moral. They said that for a man like “Yekel Shepshovitch,” keeper of a brothel, to idealize his daughter, to accept no compromise with her respectability, and for girls like Basha and Raizel, filles de joie, to dream about their dead mother, their home, and to revel in the spring rain, was unnatural."[21]
Critical reception
editThe New York production sparked a major press war between local Yiddish papers, led by the Orthodox Tageplatt and even the secular Forverts. Orthodox papers referred to God of Vengeance as "filthy," "immoral," and "indecent," while other papers described it as "moral," "artistic," and "beautiful". Some of the more provocative scenes in the production were changed, but it wasn't enough for the Orthodox papers. Even Yiddish intellectuals and the play's supporters had problems with the play's inauthentic portrayal of Jewish tradition, especially Yankl's use of the Torah, which they said Asch used for cheap effects; they also expressed concern over how it might stigmatize Jewish people who already faced anti-Semitism. The association with Jews and sex work was a popular stereotype at the time. Other intellectuals criticized the writing itself, claiming that the second act was beautifully written but the first and third acts failed to support it.[22]
References
edit- ^ Winer, Linda (2017-04-18). "'Indecent' review: Gripping, extraordinary play about a play". Newsday.
- ^ Rosenberg, Rabbi James (2020-02-06). "Exploring humanity in "God of Vengeance"". Jewish Rhode Island. Retrieved 2024-06-18.
- ^ Horwitz, Simi (2016-12-21). "But Is 'God of Vengeance' Good for the Jews?". AMERICAN THEATRE. Retrieved 2024-06-18.
- ^ "Prospect Theater – NYC LGBT Historic Sites Project". www.nyclgbtsites.org. Retrieved 2024-06-18.
- ^ Sholom Ash, The God of Vengeance, trans. Isaac Goldberg (Boston: Stratford, 1918)
- ^ "A Journey of Passion". Center Theatre Group. 2019-06-21. Retrieved 2024-06-18.
- ^ "A Journey of Passion". Center Theatre Group. 2019-06-21. Retrieved 2024-06-18.
- ^ Schiff, Ellen (1992-10-18). "THEATER; A Play With a History, Both Dramatic and Legal". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 2024-06-18.
- ^ ""The God of Vengeance": Is the Play Immoral? | The New York Public Library". www.nypl.org. Retrieved 2024-06-19.
- ^ a b Studio, Familiar (2024-06-18). "10 Things You Need to Know About…". Digital Yiddish Theatre Project. Retrieved 2024-06-18.
- ^ "YIVO | Cinema". yivoencyclopedia.org. Retrieved 2024-06-18.
- ^ "Paula Vogel | Yale 2020". yale2020.yale.edu. Retrieved 2024-06-18.
- ^ Cummings, Mike (2015-10-15). "Defending an 'Indecent' play: 'The God of Vengeance' in the Yale University Library archives". YaleNews. Retrieved 2024-06-18.
- ^ Cox, Gordon (2017-04-18). "Why the Creators of Broadway's 'Indecent' Stuck With It for 20 Years". Variety. Retrieved 2024-06-18.
- ^ Collins-Hughes, Laura (2017-04-12). "With 'Indecent,' Paula Vogel Makes Her Broadway Debut". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 2024-06-18.
- ^ "Indecent Tony Awards Wins and Nominations". www.broadwayworld.com. Retrieved 2024-06-18.
- ^ "The God of Vengeance Original Broadway Play Cast 1922 | Broadway World". www.broadwayworld.com. Retrieved 2024-06-18.
- ^ "God of Vengeance | La MaMa". www.lamama.org. Retrieved 2024-06-18.
- ^ Desk, BWW News. "Casting Complete for New Yiddish Rep's GOD OF VENGEANCE at La MaMa". BroadwayWorld.com. Retrieved 2024-06-18.
{{cite web}}:|last=has generic name (help) - ^ a b Siegel, Ben (1976). The controversial Sholem Asch: an introduction to his fiction. Bowling Green, Ohio: Bowling Green University Popular Press. ISBN 978-0-87972-076-6.
- ^ Studio, Familiar (2024-06-18). "Sholem Asch: *God of Vengeance* is…". Digital Yiddish Theatre Project. Retrieved 2024-06-19.
- ^ Stahl, Nanette, ed. (2004). Sholem Asch reconsidered. The Yale University Library gazette. New Haven, Conn: Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library. ISBN 978-0-8457-3152-9. OCLC 54279902.